Job market paperWorking paperLatest version:
Biased Information, Biased Preferences: How Fragmented Media Environments Undermine Support for Redistribution
Previously circulated as “Confirmation Bias and Asymmetric Political Polarization: Evidence from a Media Experiment in Germany”.
Abstract
When voters choose what to read about the economy, does the choice polarize what they want and whom they vote for, and does forcing the other side on them backfire? We answer with a pre-registered four-arm experiment on 4,524 German adults using two narratives about the 2022 to 2023 inflation surge. Respondents were either forced to read a left-leaning article on inflation’s regressive incidence, offered it, or offered a choice between it and a right-leaning article on growth; the three arms separately identify exposure, selection on willingness to read, and selection on the direction of what is read. Selection is confirmatory: right-leaning respondents choose the growth article at 61–67%, left-leaning at 48–52%. Exposure moves preferences toward the narrative read: forced exposure raises a redistribution index by 0.10 standard deviations, and respondents who choose the left article end 0.27 above the control group, a contrast that combines its effect with who chooses to read it. Policy by policy: the left article moves preferences on wealth, inheritance and corporate taxes; the right article moves universal basic income. The two narratives act on different margins: the left article moves policy preferences but not support for the left platforms, while respondents who choose the right article are 3.8 points more likely to rank a far-right platform first, consistent with platforms that bundle fiscal with migration positions. Backfire is narrow: forced exposure lowers UBI support only among the most right-leaning fifth, who nonetheless update their factual beliefs as fully as anyone else. Individuals do not resist the fact, instead they resist conveying from the fact to the policy.
Presented at
Code and data
German news experiment — experimental news website
odbarrerar/germannews_zew
Static front end of a mock news portal ("The Latest German News!") with category filtering and headline search, built for the German news experiment.
- Context
- Media experiment in Germany with Lora Pavlova and Li Yang (ZEW Mannheim).
- Language
- HTML · CSS · JavaScript
- Availability
- Source code of the experimental interface. No data are included.
German news experiment — companion repository
odbarrerar/germannews
Companion repository for the German news experiment.
- Context
- Media experiment in Germany with Lora Pavlova and Li Yang (ZEW Mannheim).
- Availability
- Public repository.
Cite this paper
Barrera Rodríguez, O., Pavlova, L., & Yang, L. (2026). Biased Information, Biased Preferences: How Fragmented Media Environments Undermine Support for Redistribution [Working paper]. https://odbarrerar.github.io/files/JMP_Barrera.pdf
@unpublished{barrerarodriguez2026biased,
author = {{Barrera Rodríguez}, Oscar and Pavlova, Lora and Yang, Li},
title = {{Biased Information, Biased Preferences: How Fragmented Media Environments Undermine Support for Redistribution}},
note = {Working paper},
year = {2026},
url = {https://odbarrerar.github.io/files/JMP_Barrera.pdf}
}